Back to home Robotics Cover story · 9 min read

How to scope your first cobot cell without buying the wrong arm.

Most first cobot projects stall on the parts around the robot, not the robot itself. Here is how small manufacturers scope a cell that actually runs.

A collaborative robot arm on a workbench beside a parts tray and a safety zone marked on the floor

The short version

  1. 01 Scope the task on paper first: part weight, reach, orientation and today's cycle time.
  2. 02 Part presentation and the gripper decide whether the cell runs; the arm rarely does.
  3. 03 A risk assessment can slow a collaborative arm, so check cycle time against it before buying.
  4. 04 Budget for the whole cell and give it a named owner on the floor.

The brochure version of a collaborative robot is simple: bolt it to a bench, teach it a few points with your hands, and let it work beside your people. The version that shows up on a real shop floor is messier. The arm is usually the easiest part of the project. What decides whether the cell runs is everything around it: how parts arrive, how they leave, what the gripper has to hold and what the risk assessment says about the people nearby.

That is good news for a first-time buyer, because those things can be scoped on paper before anyone signs a purchase order.

Start with the task, not the robot

Pick one job that is repetitive, steady in volume and boring enough that nobody will miss it. Machine tending, palletizing finished cartons and simple pick-and-place between two fixtures are the classic first cells for a reason: the motions repeat, the parts are known and the cycle time is easy to measure.

Then write the job down as a sequence. Where does the part come from, in what orientation, how heavy is it, where does it go and how long does a person take today? That one page is worth more than any spec sheet, because it tells you which arm you need rather than the other way round.

  1. Measure the part and the motion

    Record the heaviest part plus the gripper, the longest reach the motion needs and the cycle time a person achieves today. Payload and reach ratings are maximums, so leave a healthy margin on both.

  2. Solve part presentation

    Robots are poor at finding parts in a jumbled bin. Fixtures, trays or a simple chute that present every part in the same place and orientation are cheaper than a vision system and far more reliable.

  3. Choose the gripper early

    End-of-arm tooling often costs as much as a month of debugging. Test grip and release on real parts, including the oily, bent and out-of-tolerance ones, before you commit.

  4. Run the risk assessment before you buy

    Collaborative operation is a property of the whole application, not the arm. The assessment may limit speed, add scanners or require guarding, and that changes your cycle time.

  5. Plan the hand-off

    Decide who restarts the cell after a fault, who changes the program for a new part and who owns spare grippers. A cell nobody owns stops within a month.

Why collaborative does not mean unguarded

Standards such as ISO 10218 for industrial robots and ISO/TS 15066 for collaborative operation describe how a robot and a person can safely share space, usually by limiting the speed and force the arm can apply. In practice that means a cobot working right next to an operator often runs slower than the same arm would behind a fence.

The arm was the cheapest decision we made. The tray it picks from took three weeks.

Operations lead, contract machine shop

If the cycle time only works at full speed, plan for an area scanner that slows the arm when someone approaches, or for light guarding around the parts of the cell where people do not need to be. Neither is a failure of the cobot idea. They are simply part of the cell.

Budget for the cell, not the arm

A useful rule of thumb from integrators is that the robot itself is often well under half of a first cell's total cost. The rest goes on tooling, fixtures, safety devices, a stand or base, programming time and the hours your own people spend learning to run it. Quotes that only price the arm are quoting the easy part.

Tip

Ask for a run-off

Before final payment, ask the supplier or integrator to run your real parts for a full shift at the agreed cycle time. It surfaces gripper, fixture and safety problems while they are still the supplier's to fix.

Scoped this way, a first cobot cell stops being a bet on a robot and becomes a small, measurable change to one job. That is the version that pays for itself, and the version that earns you a second cell.

About the author

Helen Markham

Helen Markham edits the robotics and mechatronics desks. She spent nine years as a controls engineer integrating robot cells for contract manufacturers before she started writing about them, and she still reads a risk assessment before she reads a press release.

All stories by Helen 3 stories

Keep reading

Liked this?
Get five more.

For founders, engineers and operators who would rather read the spec sheet than the press release.

The Town Crier Free

Your week in industry, in five minutes.

One email on Wednesday morning. The stories worth your time this week, and nothing else.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.